Best 4 Ply Reaper Tires for Mowers and Tractors: 5 Real Picks Compared

Anyone shopping a "4 ply reaper tire" search is almost always replacing worn-out tires on a riding mower, zero-turn mower, or small garden tractor -- "Reaper" is a common turf-tire tread brand used across several mower makes, and "4 ply" tells you the sidewall's load rating. This guide is for homeowners and small-property owners who need a direct, correctly-sized replacement without ordering the wrong rim diameter or ending up with a single mismatched tire on a two-wheel drive axle.

Reaper turf tires are not one-size-fits-all -- the same tread pattern is sold in a wide range of rim diameters (8, 10, and 12 inch are the most common) and widths, so the single most important step before buying is confirming your current tire's sidewall markings against the listing.

Quick comparison

The picks

Hoosier 2-Pack 23x11.00-12 4 Ply Reaper Tire

Pros:

• Large 23x11.00-12 size suits bigger zero-turn mowers and garden tractors
• Sold as a matched pair so both drive wheels wear evenly
• Aggressive turf-friendly tread pattern for traction on slopes

Cons:

• Higher price point than single-tire listings
• Large size will not fit smaller compact mowers

Who should skip it: Skip this if your mower calls for a smaller rim size like 18 or 20 inch, or if you only need to replace one tire rather than a matched pair.

View on Amazon

20x8.00-8 4-Ply Reaper Turf Tire (Set of 2)

Pros:

• Amazon's top-selling option in this search with the highest review count here
• Common 20x8.00-8 fitment covers many residential riding mowers
• Turf-friendly tread minimizes lawn scuffing

Cons:

• 8-inch rim size won't match tractors that use 10 or 12 inch wheels
• Best suited to flatter yards rather than steep terrain

Who should skip it: Skip this if your equipment manual specifies a 10 or 12 inch wheel diameter instead of 8 inch.

View on Amazon

23x11.00-12 4 Ply Reaper Turf Tire (Single)

Pros:

• Same large 23x11.00-12 size as the Hoosier set at a lower single-tire price
• Good option when only one tire needs replacing
• Strong review rating for a lower sales-volume listing

Cons:

• Sold individually, so tread and wear won't perfectly match an older mate tire
• Lower review count than the more established sellers on this list

Who should skip it: Skip this if you need to replace both tires at once and want a guaranteed matching pair.

View on Amazon

22x11.00-10 4 Ply Reaper Tire

Pros:

• Fills the gap for 10-inch rim equipment between the 8 and 12 inch sizes above
• Reasonable price for the mid-size fitment

Cons:

• Very small review count so far, so long-term durability feedback is limited
• Only sold as a single tire, not a pair

Who should skip it: Skip this if you want a size with a longer track record of reviews, or if your equipment doesn't use a 10-inch rim.

View on Amazon

18X9.50-8 4 Ply Reaper Tire (Set of 2)

Pros:

• Compact 18x9.50-8 size fits many smaller riding mowers and zero-turns
• Sold in a matched pair for even wear on both drive wheels
• Solid rating with a reasonable number of reviews

Cons:

• Won't fit larger tractors that need the bigger 12-inch rim sizes
• Pricier per-tire than buying the single 23-inch listing above

Who should skip it: Skip this if your machine takes a larger 11 or 12 inch rim rather than the compact 8 inch size.

View on Amazon

How we chose these picks

We focused on listings that clearly state a specific tire size (never a vague "universal fit" claim), come from sellers with a track record of turf-tire sales, and carry a 4.5-star average or better across a meaningful number of reviews. We also made sure at least one single-tire option and one matched-pair option were included, since some readers only need to replace one worn tire while others are replacing both drive wheels at once. Sizes were chosen to span the most common rim diameters (8, 10, and 12 inch) so most readers can find their match without scrolling through unrelated categories like ATV or trailer tires.

Buying guide: how to confirm your size before ordering

Before ordering any replacement tire, find the size code molded into the sidewall of your current tire -- it will look something like "20x8.00-8" or "23x11.00-12". The first two numbers are the overall diameter and width in inches, and the number after the dash is the rim diameter. Match all three numbers exactly; a tire that's close but not identical can rub against the mower deck or throw off ground clearance. If you're replacing both tires on the same axle, buying a matched pair (rather than two single listings from different batches) helps keep tread wear even side to side.

Final verdict

For most riders replacing a worn set on a mid-size zero-turn or garden tractor, the 20x8.00-8 pair is the easiest all-around match given its popularity and review volume, while the Hoosier 23x11.00-12 pair suits larger machines needing the bigger 12-inch rim size. If you only need one tire rather than a pair, the single 23x11.00-12 listing is the more economical route -- just confirm your exact sidewall size against each listing before you buy, since Reaper tires span several rim diameters that are not interchangeable.